Thursday, July 3, 2025
Complex Societies Collapse when...[ finish this sentence].
Our global civilization as currently structured is unstable and unsustainable.... But with economic growth we intensify and hasten ecological collapse.
---
In simplest terms complex societies collapse when their key institutions can no longer solve the civilization's problems.
--Author Brian McClaren in Life After Doom
Saturday, June 14, 2025
Those Whom the Law Binds but does not Protect
Definition of Conservativism: “Conservatism consists of exactly one proposition: There must be in-groups whom the law protects but does not bind, alongside out-groups whom the law binds but does not protect.” -- Frank Wilhoit, Ohio Composer
Wilhoit’s insight on tribalism has stayed with me for years and is more relevant than ever. In-group and out-group. Abusers and victims. Powerful and powerless. Dominators and dominated. Conquerors and vanquished. From one angle, these are pairings of opposites, the former of each pair originating in a lack of empathy. In fact, the refusal or inability to genuinely attempt to experience another's perspective is foundational to unbalanced power dichotomies. For our purpose here, another is the other tribe, the one our tribe has no desire to protect, the one we may even, in fact, want to subjugate.
How far back does this tribalism extend? Certainly an anthropologist would answer this question with something like "millions of years," but we will not move backward that far in time today. Let's travel back to perhaps the gold standard of tribalism in United States history: The Civil War. I offer the question of who won the Civil War? Who emerged victorious over the long run? The answer is not as obvious as a document signed on April 9, 1865 at Appomattox Court House.
In fact, did the Civil War in truth end? Or did the fighting shape-shift and go underground? Reconstruction failed, or rather more correctly, was abandoned as it began to succeed. The national divisions never healed; in a genuine sense the South actually won the war, or, at least, won the peace. This is a haunting thought and an argument with great persuasive power that only grows with each passing year. One need only study the history of Reconstruction to see the evidence. The heart of the matter is the utter abandonment of the reconstruction process in the 1860-1870s, when the process was, in actuality, producing results. The Atlantic magazine dedicated an entire issue to the failure (withdrawal) of Reconstruction and the legacy of the Civil War in December 2023, an issue that highlights the ghosts of division that still haunt us.
The story of the Civil War's legacy, among other things, is a narrative steeped in fear, hatred, and lack of empathy that forced cruel divisions. The American South's chattel slavery epitomized the dearth of empathy, and the subsequent post-slavery persecution and segregation of black Americans kept festering wounds open until the present day.
Yes, the present day. Those wounds never healed. Large swaths of America never looked in the mirror and accepted the truth of the Civil War’s cruel origins and certainly never made a comprehensive attempt to take responsibility and make restitution the way Germany did for the Holocaust. Some readers may disagree and immediately point to the Civil Rights improvements in the 1960's, to which I would promptly issue the rejoinder: "The Civil Rights gains of the 1960's were the beginning of a conversation, not the end, and that conversation has been back-burnered by the current presidential administration and justice department.
And now, because of the increasing polarization, outside observers wonder if we are headed for a modern Civil War, whatever that would look like. This pre-election article by Bruce Stokes of the UK, "Could the US be headed for a National Divorce?" (Chatham House, Feb 2024) briefly highlights the stark trenches along ideological and political lines and includes this prescient - if perhaps obvious - insight : "The outcome of the 2024 US election is unlikely to resolve these differences." On target, Bruce. Right on target.
Even our former friends across the pond see, then, that destructive division will continue. Given the 2024 election, our electoral map, the astoundingly short-sighted voting bloc that put the Distended Pretender into office, and his administration's utterly atrocious, spiteful, pitiless first four months, it is difficult not to see this purposeful, architected movement toward division as perhaps the primary force - behind only capitalism itself - hindering our abilities to solve urgent issues of the day, for example, the effort to mitigate the effects of climate change.
Today's target, then, is divisiveness born of empathy-deficiency, and the us/them mindset cultivated and propagated by the current administration, its vassals, lackeys and stooges (Oh my!) and assented to by its followers. Empathy-deficiency as a theme of course pre-dates the current administration, but the MAGA forces are working overtime to perfect it.
One must employ a considerable supplementation of high school history books to uncover the unvarnished history of America, the un-whitewashed version. We can trace the history of the conservative movement's successful efforts to bring into the fold groups that by definition manifest low empathy - the gun lobby, extremist hate groups, evangelicals, anti-immigrant groups and more - back to the 1970's and before. Remember the way the ERA died a slow agonizing death? Remember Ronald Reagan opining dishonestly about welfare queens? Remember how between 1972 and 1980 the Republican party did a complete about-face on supporting gun control?
This has been an architected progression! One can see this lack of empathy on full display in the Bill of Big Bad Betrayal before Congress now, which will nullify health insurance for a projected 11 million people and add $2.4 trillion to the national debt (American Prospect). Anyone belonging to a group that is "other" deserves no health, care, right, MAGA folks? Well, at least you have your guns, I suppose. And your ignorant hatred.
In a genuine sense, then, the American dream has gone off the rails, the sense of rugged individualism corrupted to the extreme of seeking not just to ignore the government, but instead to destroy the government altogether… which is so terribly unfortunate in a time when we need inspired leadership more than ever.
Many believe, as do I, that government is a shield, not a weapon, and our government (the artificial biggest fish created for our protection) has responsibilities to shield us from the leviathan (crony capitalism, manipulation by AI/Tech, environmental destruction, foreign bad actors). Now, one can have reasonable disagreements about how much the government should help, and how far its responsibilities extend, but one cannot make a sane argument for the government's complete abdication of responsibility for its citizens' welfare in a time fraught with anxiety, manipulation by tech companies, financial uncertainty, escalating health care costs, looming climate disaster and the impending upheaval of large-scale job loss at the "hands" of AI.
Government should not be expected to solve everyone's problems, but government absolutely should mitigate pain-points involving the general welfare such as low-or-no-cost healthcare, and concerns for a safe-living environment, realms that are largely out of the typical citizen's control. To that point, government - the Federal Government of the United States - should obviously refrain from enacting policies that are purposely cruel, or laws that inflict "arbitrary and capricious" changes on the citizenry. Effective and moral government demands such an approach.
Today I highlight the current presidential administration's autocratic efforts to do just that: enact arbitrary and capricious cruelty to manipulate its base through fear and to weaponize the the base’s unfortunate black-and-white view of the world. The administration is attempting to supercharge its base's low tolerance for difference, its lack of empathy, and fear of the future.
Consider the cruelty in a wedge issue such as immigration and recent occurrences manifesting a lack of empathy, as in the pre-election demonization of Haitian immigrants. These legal immigrants in Springfield, OH, who possess protected status, were falsely accused by our autocrat and vice autocrat of eating pets (citation: go back and watch the 2024 Presidential/VP debates and the aftermath). If we broaden our scope to this week we see hundreds of thousands who had protected status are seeing it revoked arbitrarily, as Stephen Miller cackles in the background.
Or consider the glee and cruelty of the autocrat's ongoing efforts to conduct the “largest domestic deportation operation in American history” (Heather Cox Richardson, Letters from an American, May 30, 2025) along with the illegal deportation to an horrific foreign gulag of Venezuelan nationals. Then consider the cruelty of the ICE raids in Los Angeles, leading to significant mostly-peaceful protests that are absolutely justified. Including dozens more examples in this piece would be trivially easy.
Which brings me to my main point. What is empathy? Bear with me as I preface my definition with a reference to recent research conducted by Scientific American on the actual difference(s) between what we so insufficiently call conservatives and liberals.
Conservatives vs. Liberals, the essential difference: People high in hierarchical world belief [conservatives] see the world as full of differences that matter because they usually reflect something inherent, real and significant. Such individuals often separate things of greater value from things of less value. You might imagine that, to them, the world looks full of big, bold black lines.
The opposite view—held by people low in this belief—tends to perceive differences as superficial and even silly [liberals]. For individuals with this perspective, the world is mostly dotted lines or shades of gray. (To reiterate, primals concern tendencies only. Even people with a strong hierarchical world belief see some lines as arbitrary.) In our work, this primal was high in conservatives and low in liberals. --Scientific American
Even if most Americans haven’t abandoned their private sense of empathy, many don’t seem terribly bothered by the rancidness of their leaders. I confess that this indifference astonishes me. It might be the ugliest effect of Trump’s return—the rapid normalization of spectacular corruption, the desensitization to lawless power, the acceptance of moral collapse. Eventually it will coarsen us all.
Alexis Wright is an Aboriginal writer from Australia...she understands that the end of the world has been happening for centuries for indigenous people... She understands that colonizers and colonized need to be liberated from the mindset of colonization. The first step toward freedom, she says, is to decolonize or decapitalize the mind so you can develop strengths that will not be defined by how others believe you should think... she calls this liberation "sovereignty of mind."She writes, when you move into the realm of your own sovereignty of mind by shielding yourself from the kinds of interferences that rob you of the ability to think straight, that sap your spirit or block you from seeing and making your own judgment, then you're able to govern your own spirit and imagination.You can be cells of resistance, outposts of transformation, seed beds of beauty. That is the best future I can imagine for organized religion in these dangerous times. Instead of helping nostalgic people inhabit bubbles of the past, religious communities can help people go forward on this inward migration towards sovereignty of mind, we are in defiance of a rising level of ugliness, people cultivate beauty...
McClaren's advice to make your mind a cell of resistance is applicable to all communities, not just religious ones. We can all build the resistance in our minds, the one place that one can fortify and shield from virtually all outside interference. I think this is where we all have to start the process of building resistance. We start by thinking clearly, blocking interference, and reinforcing habits that will serve us in the long run. To build strength, detach from the outcomes and focus on making your mind itself a rock of moral defiance, McClaren tells us.
Popova: [Tokarczuk] reminds us that literature is also an invaluable tool of empathy [emphasis BTS]— an antidote to the divisiveness so mercilessly exploited by our “social” media.Tokarczuk: Literature is one of the few spheres that try to keep us close to the hard facts of the world, because by its very nature it is always psychological, because it focuses on the internal reasoning and motives of the characters, reveals their otherwise inaccessible experience to another person, or simply provokes the reader into a psychological interpretation of their conduct. Only literature is capable of letting us go deep into the life of another being, understand their reasons, share their emotions and experience their fate.
The point here is that literature is enjoyable for its own sake but is also a tool for practicing empathy, as it requires us to enter into the mind of its characters and inspect their motives, behaviors and inner life. By inspecting the motives and behaviors and inner life of imaginary characters, we access a safe sandbox for difficult conversations with the characters and ourselves and gain insight into our own inner life. Perhaps we also increase our empathy, and in that regard hopefully we expand the in-group in our lives to include far more of those folks that the law binds but does not protect.
Tuesday, May 27, 2025
WTFJHT
Recently one of my comments was included in a compilation of responses to an editor's note/request on the WTFJHT newsletter's May 27, 2025 edition, linked here. The Pinboard is only available in the emailed newsletter, not on the website, so I have pasted the responses to the editor's note at the bottom of this post.
WTFJHT (WTF Just Happened Today?) is "A political newsletter for normal people."
Author Matt Kiser's tagline for his newsletter is "a sane, once-a-day newsletter helping normal people make sense of the news. Curated daily and delivered to 200,000+ people every afternoon around 3 pm Pacific."
My comment, in response to Kiser's request, is printed below in crimson font.
Editor Matt Kaiser's note: At the bottom of today’s edition are some of your anonymous reactions to the House passing Trump’s “One Big Beautiful Bill” by a single vote to expand corporate tax breaks, repeal clean energy credits, cut Medicaid and food aid, and add $2.3 trillion to the debt. The responses are raw, urgent, and deeply personal. And, they tell the story not of politics, but of people facing real consequences of these policies.
The Pinboard, May 27, 2025
"I am afraid and frankly angry that our future as a society looks like poverty and desperation." –Anonymous
"As a nurse who spent the first couple decades of my career taking care of vulnerable kids who relied on both Medicare and Medicaid to cope with the results of extreme prematurity, complex congenital cardiac diagnoses and heart transplants, I can’t imagine what will happen to these kids and families." –Anonymous
"Don't Republicans want a better world for their children? What good is it to hand your children a pile of gold and a mansion if you live in a world akin to the setting of Mad Max? In a broken world, money can only buy security for so long." –BTS
"All I can say is I wonder if this is how the Germans felt watching their country being taken over by lunatics and sycophants..." –Anonymous
"As a teen father whose son is on state healthcare losing Medicaid would be a heavy blow to me and my family. Having to pay insane premiums or not having health insurance at all could drive us well into the ground. I don’t know what to do." –Anonymous
"Prior to the Affordable Care Act, healthcare was inaccessible to me. I was a single mother, with next to no resources, raising a small child. Because of my epilepsy, the best plan I could get was going to be $1000/month. It was out of the question. The choice before me was life-saving meds or food for my child. As I’ve aged and developed new conditions, Medicaid has saved me from bankruptcy and homelessness. What’s heartbreaking is that this story isn’t unique. This is the American dream?" –Anonymous
"I am supposed to get a kidney transplant this fall which would save my life, but that is now in dire jeopardy because of cuts to Medicaid, Medicare and rural health support of all sorts. This may literally cost me my life. That pisses me off." –Anonymous
"I was diagnosed with cancer in May [...] and I nearly died at the end of January. The good news is that the cancer is gone. The bad news is that I have to have an MRI and colonoscopy every six months for at least two years. My medical bills have been astronomical, but fortunately I have 'only’ had to pay out 20k. So, now, I have a serious pre-existing condition and if Medicaid is cut, my health insurance will be in peril. I am terrified." –Anonymous
"This whole thing just feels like a death march to the end of democracy and the vast majority of the population is distracted by the shiny object over there instead of the guillotine straight ahead." –Anonymous
"What's happening now is deliberate deconstruction of every piece of physical, intellectual and social infrastructure that makes a country viable, growing and competitive in a global economy." –Anonymous
"I work in in-home caregiving and 90% of our clients are Medicaid funded. This bill is going to leave millions of people without care. It’s absolutely disgusting and stomach-churning, because I know what happens when those people aren't supported – they die." –Anonymous
"I’m terrified that my as-yet-unborn children won’t ever have the chance to afford living on their own, and they won’t know what the world was like before climate change destroyed every single country. Someday they might see an old map of what the world looks like today and I don’t know if they’ll recognize it." –Anonymous
"What future are we building? There is no future vision for us, just a desire for power and wealth for a few, and a march to dystopia for the rest." –Anonymous
"Life is far too short to spend it living in fear. To get through this, we will all need to learn how to be brave, bold, and beautiful. Don’t forget who you are out of fear of being who they hate. The better world that we will build together will be built in the ashes of this crumbling empire - and I promise that better days are ahead." –Anonymous
Please support WTFJHT at https://whatthefuckjusthappenedtoday.com/
Saturday, May 24, 2025
To what exactly do you object?
- Executive order to end birthright citizenship
- The January 6th Pardons
- Attacking the free press.
- Attacking higher education
- Attacking law firms with petty and dangerous executive orders.
- Massive deportations- creating a culture of fear.
- Deportations with no due process.
- Defying the Supreme Court.
- Insane tax cuts.
- Weaponizing the IRS
- Anything remotely related to DOGE which will probably cost us money after all the lawsuits, pain, and cruelty.
- DOGE's having compromised our personal information.
- Gutting health and human services and putting a wacko in charge which will undoubtedly lead to more measles deaths, among other things.
- Ridiculous gutting of government services to pass tax cuts for the rich.
- Cutting funding and personnel to the national parks.
- Ruining our reputation completely destroying our relationships with allies.
- All the lies he's told about Ukraine.
- Destroying our relationship with the EU.
- The obvious preparations that are now being made to undermine the next elections (3rd term)
- The Canada and Greenland business
- The support of the toxic masculinity culture.
- Attacking the LGBT community
- Pete Hegseth's complete incompetence as Secretary of Defense
- The Tariffs
- Peter Navarro's wackadoodle economic theories
- Defying the courts
- Preparing to cut Medicaid, Medicare, and social security
The Patchwork of Pulling Threads
Pulling threads, in the sense that I use it, is the process of searching for insight indirectly, gently agitating or stimulating one's mind with seemingly unrelated details, tasks, or other projects until suddenly an insight comes into focus. This includes working at a piece of writing or other artwork in fits and starts, brainstorming, trying new approaches until something works.
Pulling Threads is a labor of love, a patchwork journal to document my intellectual forays and preserve my sanity. Selections will include essays, opinions, poetry, artwork, observations, excerpts, passages, favorite quotes, ideas, lamentations, excoriations, and possibly debates. This blog will undoubtedly evolve.
My purpose in this endeavor is to document in snapshots our strange and alarming period of history and in many cases refine and share my thoughts and opinions on life in America in what could be the latter days of Democracy (or perhaps just the latter days, period.) I do not utter such a warning lightly; I will strive to speak clearly and eschew hyperbole.
Often I may post a link, quote, story or photograph and then respond to it in short form. As such, my aim is not a research project, but rather an effort to think rationally throughout the coming chaos and the post-truth onslaught.
Some posts may be as succinct as one memorable quote that I offer for the purpose of clearly laying out an argument or opinion in the future. -BTS
We'll start with a quote from one of my favorite authors:
“You must stay drunk on writing so reality cannot destroy you.”
― Ray Bradbury, Zen in the Art of Writing: Releasing the Creative Genius Within You
And, I almost forgot to mention humor, which will undoubtedly infuse my posts here and there.
We are well on our way now. Roads go ever on and on.
That's all. For now, onward, to what future, I do not know.
Friday, May 23, 2025
Thursday, May 22, 2025
Flight Risk - Poem
"Flight Risk" is a poem I wrote in 2023 and includes a companion piece of digital artwork. No associated commentary is necessary. I will post the artwork separately.
Flight Risk
by Brian Seiler
I.
Unsettled sleep of late, that struggle
to quiet the networked marionettes,
those storming mouths like murder holes
And so: At night I dream of escaping –
over the Alps or maybe the Berlin Wall –
in grieving hot air balloons, buffed in soot
to match the bruised horizon
Days fade
We hide in gaslit castle passages
sheltered by tapestries of rain splattering the silent stones
II.
Whether past or future scenes
these are not dreams – no –
but rather survival routines
Often with a partner, shrewd children
and boots with buckshot soles
An odd way to sooth myself to sleep – perhaps–
but I have built my barriers.
For now I have forced the fascists to sulk in shadow
ever sharpening their long knives
III.
At night we walk, always a whisper ahead
Every step brings solace in skirting the searchlights
but in daylight the black robes, gathered six over three,
intone the founding myth: smiles and smiles and villainous lies
fueled by – why dissemble? – fear, immeasurable
And so with city sirens whining
we unfold worn blankets, hope forged
from priceless passports sewn into linings
-
Thought for the Day: Our global civilization as currently structured is unstable and unsustainable.... But with economic growth we intensify...
-
A posting from Barry F in the comments over at Tangle arguing that the attacks on the free press are serious and dangerous. I fully agree wi...
-
Definition of Conservativism: “Conservatism consists of exactly one proposition: There must be in-groups whom the law protects but does not ...
